June 25, 2010

Review of "The Silent Governess" by Julie Klassen


"The Silent Governess," despite it's intimidating 50 chapters, was a truly interesting read, and despite some drawbacks, I would recommend it for a light read.

Klassen's plot was beautifully weaved into a complete web that is difficult to fully anticipate. Her plot line was definitely the strongest part of the book. From the beginning to end every event had significance. But her character's lacked true development and consistency.

The two main characters, Lord Bradley and Olivia, have a very odd and semi-abusive relationship. Not to give away the plot, but Olivia overhears something about Lord Bradley that would be disastrous for anyone to hear. She is caught in the act, though innocent of devious intent, and he forces her to stay on as a nurse so that he can keep an eye on her. He's afraid that she will give him away, or try to blackmail him. And because of his fear he is highly abusive to her. He threatens her verbally many times, and accuses her of horrible deeds. She has just come from an abusive situation at home and it seems to me she would be unlikely to put up with his behavior towards her, especially since Klassen tries to portray Olivia as a strong, independent woman, almost like an Elizabeth Bennet.

Some of the dialogue is truly atrocious, and the situations a bit unlikely. But despite that the plot really was redeeming. You can't help but read it to learn what is really going on in this tangled web of relationships and events. I, of course, love the Regency time period, and the back of the book stating that Klassen loves everything Jane: Jane Austen and Jane Eyre, endears me to her.

I would recommend this book to anyone who doesn't mind ignoring the characters and dialogue in favor of the truly complicated plot line.

No comments:

Post a Comment